Key Takeaways
- Companies often get locked into false dichotomies, should we acquire this company or not, hire this executive or not, and that either-or framing puts blinders on the decision-making process.
- Widening your pool of options produces a much better decision, but it's hard to do in the heat of the planning session, so start early and engage your team in a Think Rhythm before the meeting where you'll actually decide.
- Don't use your strategic planning session to bless what you've already decided or to debate endlessly over one option; generate more possibilities first.
- Once you have a pool of possible strategies, narrow them with an objective framework, ranking ideas by revenue impact and ability to execute, test your assumptions, and explore multiple ideas simultaneously to avoid getting locked into a losing strategy.

Generate more possibilities for your business strategy.
-
If we waved a magic wand and suddenly we could NOT do any of the options we've identified up to this point, what would we do instead?
-
If we were replaced today by a new team of top executives, what's the first thing they would do? What's stopping us from doing the same thing?
-
If you were in your CEO forum or other professional group and one of your peers described the same business challenge you are having, what advice would you offer?
-
How can we do something small to test our ideas before we invest? (As Jim Collins says, fire bullets before cannonballs.)
-
Who has already solved this problem or achieved this goal? What can you learn from them?
-
Are there any useful analogies you can apply? What can you learn from other industries, disciplines, or leaders?
-
If we zoom to the future and we are celebrating a year from now, what have we done to achieve that success? (This is the Destination Postcard exercise our consultants encourage clients to do in their Annual Planning process.)
-
If we zoom to the future and we have failed miserably a year from now, what has gone wrong? How can we protect ourselves from these potential pitfalls?
-
If we are wildly successful with our idea, what could go wrong that we should plan for? (Think supply chain issues, operational challenges, etc.)
-
If we fail spectacularly, what's Plan B? What is a leading indicator that we can use to know if we are on track for failure? What's the threshold for shifting to Plan B to mitigate the damage? (Think of setting a tripwire to get an early alert that you need to change course.)
Use Rhythm Software to move seamlessly from strategic planning to execution.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you make better decisions in a strategic planning session?
Widen your pool of options before you decide. Companies that frame decisions as whether-or-not questions put blinders on the process. Start your planning early so you have time to think creatively, generate more possibilities with your team in a Think Rhythm before the session, and then narrow the options with an objective framework.
What is a false dichotomy in strategic planning?
It's getting locked into an either-or decision: should we acquire this company or not, hire this executive or not, build this feature or not. That framing prevents the team from stepping back and asking what else those resources could do entirely, which is often where the better decision lives.
How do you pressure-test a strategy before committing?
Zoom to the future in both directions. Picture celebrating success a year from now and describe what you did to get there (the Destination Postcard exercise used in Annual Planning). Then picture failing miserably and ask what went wrong. Define a Plan B, a leading indicator that tells you you're on track for failure, and a threshold for shifting to Plan B, like a tripwire that gives you an early alert to change course.
How do you narrow down strategic ideas once you have them?
Use an objective framework: rank ideas by revenue impact and ability to execute, then test your assumptions. Explore multiple ideas simultaneously if you can, so you don't get locked into a losing strategy.
How can software support strategic planning decisions?
Rhythm software lets you create Idea Boards in your Annual Planning Meeting so the team can brainstorm asynchronously and keep all the prep work organized in one place. When you decide which ideas to execute, you can convert an Idea to a Goal with one click to move seamlessly from strategic planning to execution.
Jessica Wishart
Jessica is Senior Product Manager at Rhythm Systems. She has experience in Client Services and Rhythm software technical support. Her background is in Organizational Execution.
Connect with me on LinkedIn.
