backAll Articles

Published August 29, 2023 at 04:47 PM

How to Create a KPI in 5 Simple Steps

4 min read
How to Create a KPI in 5 Simple Steps
2:21
4 min read
How to Create a KPI in 5 Simple Steps
2:21

Key Takeaways

  • Most companies start KPI creation with the wrong question, "What do we need to measure in each department?", which produces 18 to 25 KPIs, little progress a quarter later, and a return to business as usual by the third quarter.
  • The right starting question is "What business problem do I need to solve?" Pick one problem for the company that is bugging you and impeding your progress.
  • Measure progress with a leading indicator that shows where you are going, not where you have been, and set SMART Red-Yellow-Green success criteria so you know if the goal is on track.
  • The secret of success is not in the KPI itself but in the actions you take to move it toward your goal, so decide in advance what you will do when the KPI is Red or Yellow.
  • Start with just 1 or 2 KPIs, get value, succeed, then pick a few more; focusing on a couple each quarter builds 8 to 10 action-oriented KPIs that really make an impact on your business.

The common mistake many companies make is to start creating a bunch of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for their company. They begin with a burst of energy, gather together the team, and work on KPIs in a quarterly planning session. They ask, "What do we need to measure in each department?" This produces 18 to 25 KPIs, a couple for each key executive to work on. Convinced they have changed the company, they dash off excited to see what results they will generate in the upcoming quarter. They should ask,, "How do I create a KPI that measures my team's performance?"  A quarter later, many are demoralized, and little progress has been made measuring these KPIs. They lose steam, and by the 3rd quarter, it's back to business as usual.

I have seen this many times before... If this resonates with you or you are wincing, then please read on.

The problem is that they started with the wrong question. "What do we need to measure in each department?" or "How do I create a KPI?" They should ask, "What business problem do I need to solve?"

How To Create a KPI

  1. What problem do I need to solve? Pick one for the company that is bugging you and impeding your progress.

  2. How do I measure progress? Use a leading indicator to measure where you are going, not where you have been.

  3. What are the SMART Red-Yellow-Green success criteria to determine if the goal is on track?

  4. What actions should I take to get it, Green, when it is off track? 

  5. What should I do when it's Red or Yellow? What action can I take from the measurement to improve it?

Start with just 1 or 2 KPIs. The secret of success is not in the KPI. The secret of success is in the actions you take to move the KPI towards your goal, not in the measurement itself. Don't measure everything that moves; measure what you want. Rather than having 18-25 KPIs, just do 1 or 2. Focus on the actions, get value, succeed, and then pick a few more to focus on. Actually creating a repeatable and sustainable process, not doing an event. Write out your path of progress as you create a KPI dashboard that works for you and your team.

If you focus on a couple of KPIs each quarter, before you know it, you will have 8-10 KPIs that are action-oriented KPIs that really make an impact on your business.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you create a KPI?

Start with the question "What business problem do I need to solve?" rather than "What do we need to measure?" Then work through five steps: pick one problem that is impeding your progress, choose a leading indicator to measure where you are going, set SMART Red-Yellow-Green success criteria to determine if the goal is on track, define the actions you will take to get it back to Green when it is off track, and act on the measurement when it turns Red or Yellow.

How many KPIs should a company start with?

Start with just 1 or 2. Don't measure everything that moves; measure what you want. If you focus on a couple of KPIs each quarter, before you know it you will have 8 to 10 action-oriented KPIs that make a real impact on your business.

Why do most KPI initiatives fail?

Companies typically gather the team in a quarterly planning session, ask what each department needs to measure, and walk out with 18 to 25 KPIs. A quarter later many are demoralized because little progress has been made, they lose steam, and by the third quarter it is back to business as usual. The problem is starting with the wrong question instead of a specific business problem to solve.

What matters more, the KPI or the actions behind it?

The actions. The secret of success is not in the measurement itself; it is in the actions you take to move the KPI toward your goal. A KPI only creates value when it triggers adjustments, which is why you should define what you will do when it turns Red or Yellow before you start measuring.

Picture of Patrick Thean

Patrick Thean
Patrick is an award-winning serial entrepreneur, a WSJ and USA Today bestselling author, CEO Coach, and Co-founder of Rhythm Systems.
LinkedIn Connect with me on LinkedIn.